Which Exam is Easier to Clear: IAS or IPS?

The Indian Administrative Service (IAS) and the Indian Police Service (IPS) are both prestigious civil services in India and are recruited through the same examination process conducted by the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC). However, there are nuances to consider regarding the difficulty of clearing each exam. In this article, we will explore the key differences and factors that might make one service easier to clear than the other.

Comparison Between IAS and IPS Exams

UPSC Civil Services Examination (CSE)

Both IAS and IPS officers are selected through the UPSC CSE. The exam consists of three stages:

Preliminary Examination (Prelims) Main Examination (Mains) Personality Test (Interview)

Preliminary Examination

Common for both IAS and IPS aspirants.

Consists of two objective-type papers: General Studies Paper I and General Studies Paper II (CSAT). Qualifying in nature and serves as a screening test for the Mains.

Main Examination

Written examination consisting of nine papers:

Essay General Studies 4 Two Optional Subject Papers Two Language Papers (one of which is qualifying in nature)

Marks obtained in these papers are considered for the final ranking.

Personality Test

Interview conducted by a board to assess the personality of the candidate.

Marks obtained in the interview are added to the marks of the Mains to determine the final ranking.

Differences and Specific Considerations

While the fundamental difficulty level of clearing both exams is the same, there are differences in competition, preparation strategy, and physical requirements that might make one seem easier than the other depending on individual strengths and circumstances.

Competition and Ranking

IAS: Generally considered the top choice among candidates resulting in higher competition. A higher rank is usually required to secure a position in the IAS. IPS: Though highly prestigious, the IPS typically requires a slightly lower rank compared to the IAS, making it relatively easier to get into if your rank isn’t at the very top.

Physical Requirements

IAS: Primarily focuses on intellectual and administrative capabilities with no stringent physical requirements. IPS: Requires candidates to meet specific physical standards and pass physical fitness tests. This can be a challenge for some aspirants, adding an additional layer of difficulty for the IPS.

Preparation Strategy

The preparation for both services is largely similar due to the common examination process. Candidates need to focus on:

Comprehensive coverage of the syllabus Current affairs Developing answer writing skills Choosing an optional subject based on personal interests

Career Preferences and Aptitude

IAS: Offers diverse roles in various sectors such as administrative, developmental, and policy-making positions. If you have a strong inclination towards policy-making and administration, this might be more suitable. IPS: Involves law enforcement, maintaining public order, and dealing with crime. If you have a passion for policing and maintaining law and order, this might be the better choice.

Conclusion

There isn't a definitive answer to whether the IAS or IPS exam is easier to clear, as both are part of the same rigorous UPSC CSE process. The decision largely depends on personal preferences, career aspirations, and individual strengths.

Whether you choose the IAS or IPS, success requires dedicated preparation, strategic planning, and consistent hard work. The IAS might be the better fit if you are more inclined towards administrative roles, policy-making, and governance, and are ready to compete at the highest level for the top ranks.

If you have a strong interest in law enforcement, maintaining public order, and can meet the physical requirements, the IPS could be a fulfilling career path with slightly less competitive pressure at the top ranks.